If you want the most tender, juicy taco meat with blistered, crispy edges, this smoked pork carnitas recipe delivers! It freezes & reheats beautifully, too.
PREHEAT: Follow the setup instructions for your pellet grill, I used our Traeger Pro Series 34. Set the temperature to 225 F / 107 C with the probes on the outside of the grill.
RUB: Mix all of the dry rub ingredients, from coconut sugar to black pepper, together in a bowl. Set about 1/4 of the mixture (about 2 tablespoons / 33 g or so) aside for later. Rub the pork on all sides with the seasoning blend, including any incisions into the middle of the meat where the bone was removed.
SMOKE: Place the rubbed pork shoulder into a roasting pan and pour the broth and orange juice around but not over the top of the meat. (If you’re using a disposable foil roaster, make sure to place it on a baking sheet, too.) Place the uncovered pork onto the grill, place the two meat probes (if you have them built into your pellet grill) at even intervals so that they’re equidistant from both each other and each end of the roast. Close the lid and smoke until the probes record an internal temperature of 160 F / 71 C, about 4 hours. Start checking the internal temperature of the pork after the first 2 hours.
WRAP: Lay out two pieces of foil large enough to wrap around the pork. Carefully transfer the pork from the roasting pan to the foil, then wrap snugly with the first layer of foil. Repeat with the second layer of foil so that the seam of the foil faces upwards on the top of the pork roast. Reserve the pan juices for later by pouring them into a fat separator and popping that in the fridge. (If you have room in the fridge, throw the roasting pan in there, too.)
ROAST: Place the foil wrapped pork back into the pellet grill, replacing the temperature probes. Roast until the internal temperature reaches 201 F / 94 C, about 90 minutes or so. Start to check on the temperature after the first hour, as the size and thickness of the pork will make the final cook time vary a little.
REST: Carefully wrap the still foil wrapped pork in a double layer of old towels, then place the towel wrapped pork into an insulated cooler bag. Rest the pork like this for 60 – 120 minutes.
PULL: Unwrap the pork and discard the foil. Transfer the pork to a large chopping board and pull it into chunks, using a couple of forks because the pork will still be plenty hot! Transfer the pulled pork back to the roasting pan you stashed in the fridge. Add back the strained, de-fatted juices you reserved earlier to the pork a little at a time. Use as much of the roasting juices as you need, tossing the meat to coat, until the pork is juicy without being swimming in liquid. You likely won’t need to use all of it! Taste the pork and, if you think it needs additional seasoning, add a little of the reserved seasoning blend, to taste.
CRISP: Preheat a cast iron skillet or large cast iron griddle pan over medium high heat, depending on how much of the pork you want to crisp at a time. Oil generously and then pack the pork into a single layer and cook until a deeply caramelized crust develops, about 2 minutes or so. Flip the pork over so that the softer meat mixes in with the crispy pieces and repeat until the smoked pork carnitas is as crispy as you like. Serve immediately with your favorite fixings, like my Foolproof Grain Free Tortillas, No Nightshade Roasted Green Onion Salsa Verde, Strawberry Guacamole or Lime Pickled Red Onions.