This Paleo White Chocolate Mousse actually started off life as a panna cotta recipe. I don’t know if it happens a lot to other people, but I have a pretty consistent habit of changing my mind or experimenting mid way through a recipe.
I’d had my heart set on making a lovely grass fed gelatin based dessert ever since someone asked me for a recipe. So I happily set out to make a coconut milk panna cotta. Then I got to debating whether or not I should flavor it. I wanted to keep things light, so went with fresh lemon zest.
But then it happened. That moment when I went completely insane and found another ingredient that was just too tempting to put down. The intoxicatingly scented raw cacao butter was calling to me. Mmmm, cacao-y goodness! I mean, what could go wrong with adding a hint of white chocolate to something that was fragrant with lemon zest?
As it turns out, quite a bit. Because after I hurriedly threw my ingredients together and then waited an almost torturous amount of time for my dessert to chill and set… I got a mouthful of grainy, sand-like chocolate flavored stuff. It was not good. I mean, the flavor was fantastic. White chocolate and lemon is fantastic together. But there was no getting around the grossness of that texture. So now I will share with you exactly what I did to salvage that sand-fest of a dessert. Hoorah!
How to make Paleo White Chocolate Mousse
The first time that I made my Paleo White Chocolate Mousse, I melted all of my ingredients together, including my delicious raw cacao butter, before adding my grass fed gelatin. Then I just poured the mixture off into molds and waited expectantly. The problem with that plan? Cacao butter is a fat. So when it cooled down and then chilled in the refrigerator, the cacao butter separated from the other ingredients. And rose to the top of my molds, creating a layer of pure fat. Mmm, yummy. Paleo White Chocolate should not have a layer of pure fat on the top. Or bottom, depending on whether you used silicone tartlet molds like I did, or cute little ramekins for your desserts.
It was this layer of cacao butter fat which was making the horrible grainy texture. It also didn’t look so pretty. Plus, just to finish things off, instead of having a Paleo White Chocolate dessert, I had a layer of cacao butter and… a layer of set coconut gelatin. But the Paleo White Chocolate? It didn’t really exist because the ingredients wouldn’t stay incorporated. I needed to somehow get the fat from the cacao butter to emulsify so that when I chilled the Paleo White Chocolate Mousses, the ingredients would no longer separate. So here’s what I did.
- Bloomed my grass fed gelatin in a little water.
- Added all of my other Paleo White Chocolate Mousse ingredients to a saucepan and warmed them gently.
- Added the bloomed grass fed gelatin to the saucepan when the cacao butter had melted.
- Once the grass fed gelatin had dissolved, I poured everything into my blender and processed it for about 30 seconds: this emulsified the fats and created lovely air bubbles.
- Poured the Paleo White Chocolate Mousse mixture into adorable little silicone tartlet molds and waited eagerly for them to set.
The result? Perfectly smooth Paleo White Chocolate Mousses with a glorious hint of lemon. Yay! I decided to top my Paleo White Chocolate Mousses off with a Cranberry-Apple Compote: the tart-sweet fruit combination made a lovely pairing, if I do say so myself! These would be a great holiday dessert – got to make the most out of cranberry season! You can top the Paleo White Chocolate Mousses with the compote if you’re using ramekins or Mason jars to plate, or make molded versions like I did that can swim on a pool of cranberry goodness instead. Up to you!
PAID ENDORSEMENT DISCLOSURE: In order for me to support my blogging activities, I may receive monetary compensation or other types of remuneration for my endorsement, recommendation, testimonial and/or link to any products or services from this blog. See my affiliate link policy here.
AMAZON DISCLOSURE: The owner of this website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon properties including, but not limited to, amazon.com, endless.com, myhabit.com, smallparts.com, or amazonwireless.com.